It came out of left field as I didn’t think it would even be a contender, but it was to die for. After sampling quite a few flavors such as Fluffernutter, Mint Chip and Ginger I actually ended up settling on a scoop of Honeycomb. They have unique, but not insane flavors that are all SO delicious. It was both of our favorites by a long shot. I am still dreaming about this ice cream. We like to think we walked off most of it in the 12+ miles we walked between all of the shops and it was research so… Here are our opinions on the shops from best to worst! Still, if you do the math that is A LOT of ice cream. Luckily we were able to sample flavors at almost every location and in most cases bought 1 ice cream to share. The second half of our NYC Ice Cream Trip was spent visiting 7 ice cream shops in 24 hours.